I do like them for sure – I think if I had to choose another brand that does it well, it’s Aeotec. For some reason I find their products aesthetically appealing and I like their style.
Yeah totally – this is what we were going after with the hype video you referenced – “Next Generation of Smart Switches”, which hopefully implied that there are normal switches and there are the next generation of smart switches. Love the idea of smarter though!
LOL – if you watch the MacBook Pro video from above, you’ll notice we took some inspiration here
Fantastic, I agree! Why would you choose a status-quo switch, when you can have one that is a lifestyle switch which makes things easier for you?
I remember when we were in NYC with the agency that worked on designing our site and overall branding and one of the things that stuck with me as we were out enjoying way too many Old Fashions, was that one of the guys said, “you need something that distinguishes you from the rest” – think of Apple, you know when you see an Apple product, it’s an Apple product. Same with cars – you can generally tell the style of car manufacturers.
Once you have that, “distinctive asset” (Kellogg words… sorry for going corporate), market it hard so when people see it, they know it’s you. This is where the inspiration of the LED bar and config button came from. I think @OverneathCreative nailed this in the Fan/Light video’s intro where it teases these LED bars and shows how awesome they look.
Interesting take – I see your point. I think we looked at it more as what cars do in that the models are always the same, except it’s a 2019 or 2020, etc, Gen 5. I know we changed the model # for the Gen 1 vs Gen 2, but that was because we change manufacturers and the, “N” stood for our old manufacturer’s name whereas the, “L” stands for the new manufacturer’s name.
Agree.
Nailed it. This is our biggest struggle and opportunity. It’s been a challenge for 4+ years to pack all this technology into a product and then bundle it up into a marketing campaign that explains what we do to the novice user. I think we’re finally getting there, but another challenge is the hubs haven’t been able to keep up and most of them you need to piece together code to really unlock the features and this is something the average person does not want to do – just ask this guy who was a treat to talk to on Reddit, but he brought to life the problem with products that have a lot to offer, mainstream hubs, and lack of control from our end to control the environment.
That’s where a license agreement with someone who’s open to us tweaking their firmware and UI to make our products work out of the box will hopefully come in handy.
Happy to share – I’ll PM you. Anyone else who is interested, I’m happy to share as well.
Yeah, this is such a good point and it’s one that has haunted us – this and the 4-1 Sensor. We were at a point where B2B companies showed interest in these and the manufacturer was wanting us to sell them. Add that to the fact that we didn’t have the extra money to innovate and pay for our new ideas yet and we went with a white-label. Big mistake and very off brand. In order to add firmware tweaks to these products, they would have to be re-certified and that costs a decent chunk of change, so we just went with the stock firmware.
Major lesson learned there for sure and my gut told me not to do it initially as what’s made us successful is the innovative firmware and more recently innovated hardware (Gen 2 switches). Lesson is… trust your gut. We could’ve waited out a few more months and had the Fan/Light and another innovative item (Project BFF or Windy City).
Awesome, this is great to hear – one of the things we were shooting for was to capture as much of the market as we could with the Gen 2’s – especially the dimmers. Neutral and Non-Neutral market… Aux switch and dumb switch market. I literally didn’t think it was possible, but the engineers pulled it off (6 months late, but who’s counting?) and we hit a home run with them. They’ve outsold our Gen 1’s 3-1 and our Gen 1’s sold a ton. Combine that with the great community and we have unstoppable firmware that accounts for 99.9% of what people could want.
Yes, exactly – this is quite the challenge and quite the vetting process with existing brands.
I’ll send over that pitch deck… I think we’re on the same page
Yeah exactly – we were talking to a European Hub Company not too long ago that offered a lot of the bells and whistles (no local control… boo) but they were going to sell it for $300. It has an amazing UI and lots of partnerships and a great community, but that’s a tough mountain to climb in the US where you have established brands selling for $75 and other more powerful hubs selling for $130ish. Very difficult to compete there, even if you had the best hub, the DIY market isn’t going to pay a premium if the story isn’t compelling enough and even then, most of what I’d ever need to do can be bought for $75-$125.
Full disclosure, we plan on eliminating the ilumin brand and just sticking with Inovelli. We originally launched it to protect the Inovelli brand in case the bulbs flopped, but luckily they didn’t. Also, the vibrant colors didn’t seem on brand for Inovelli at the time, but I think we can pull it off now
Haha yes, never saw that one before. However for the evolution shots at the beginning, your video is better IMHO, mainly because of the music… the buildup suggests something big is coming, then the audible ‘let me introduce to you’ with visual ‘the future’. I just don’t like how the music stops at 0:19 and kind of peters out. I think it should stay strong for the whole rest of the ad. I hope someday you guys recut that, music stays stronger to the end, and focus on what the switch can do for the customer rather than what the switch can do. IE instead of ‘make life more colorful’ (which sounds aesthetic), show a couple 0.5-1.5 second examples of it in action. I think that ad is about halfway to being a true masterpiece…
Agreed. And the notification examples are great too.
Yes but cars have model numbers too. A 2020 Honda Accord LX has a model number like CV1F1LEW. 2019 Accord Sport is CV1F3KEW. They’d never do CV1F3KEW v2.
I think like cars, there end up being 3 identifiers:
The general product name (Inovelli Red Series Dimmer / Honda Accord)
The specific product name (Inovelli Red Series Dimmer v2 / 2020 Honda Accord LX)
The model number (LZW31-SN / CV1F1LEW).
Just like the car, most customers won’t care too much about the exact version / model #, other than to know they are getting the latest one. But you should make them intuitive. A minor tweak to product design should have a minor model # change, IE LZW31-SN2 would be if a minor hardware improvement was made. A whole revamp like switching to a 700 chipset should have a new model # IE LZW41-SN.
Agreed. That also IMHO is one of the biggest advantages of making a ZigBee powered Red dimmer- you only have two targets to hit (Google and Amazon), and if you can hit those dead on you have a perfect customer experience for literally millions of potential users.
I don’t think you should. Something being popular doesn’t mean it’s true to brand. I like the ilumin bulbs and will probably buy one or two more because they are functional and cost effective. But with their current firmware, popular or not, your gut is right- they aren’t up to the Inovelli standard and shouldn’t be brought under the Inovelli brand.
The bulbs make money and you’re going to keep selling them, right? I think you should. That’s where iLumin is perfect. Expand and do other white label products, just make the distinction with the branding. But keep them out of Inovelli. If a customer has to look up which products are ‘true’ inovelli and which ones are white label, that dilutes your brand a lot.
If anything, I think you should expand iLumin. Find other white label products, that you can vet and make sure are good, and sell them under the iLumin name. Thus the main brand is protected, but you can still make some money on volume of white label products without the R&D upfront.
Only reason not to do it (maybe) is areas where it cannibalizes your main product line. For example, I suggest don’t sell an iLumin dimmer switch, even if it is a white label without Inovelli industrial design. OTOH, Steve Jobs once said ‘if we don’t cannibalize our own product line, someone else will do it for us…’
That is one valid reason against the white label- if getting white label / iLumin to market distracts your team or the manufacturer from the core mission of Inovelli products, that’s a Bad Thing. If I could rewrite history and kill the smart bulb but have a Project BFF in hand right now, I’d push that button without a second’s hesitation.
Actually that gives me another idea- a recipe book. This would be a PDF document of several pages, with family friendly illustrations, that takes a Red dimmer, puts it in several use cases around the home, and shows which options one would configure to do that. I stumbled into this on my own ‘heyyyy… if I just tweak the configs I can put these everywhere with no forethought and they do everything!’ but a recipe book would help push that message. For example: Patio floodlight. Rarely needs dimming, except when we set up the projector and watch movies. Set options: default ramp rate zero, local ramp rate 5 seconds, delay override enable. Result- pushing up or down instantly turns light on/off, but holding dims the bulb. Have a bunch of those with some pretty pictures. On the front page, put something like ‘The Red dimmer is the most flexible light switch on the market today. It can be the right switch for almost any application, removing the need to select different switches or dimmers for each location. Here’s some ways you can use it…’
To quote the great Shigero Miyamoto- “A late game is only late until it ships. A bad game is bad until the end of time.” While that’s not quite true anymore now that software updates are a thing, the principle still holds. A late product is only late until it ships. Once it goes out the door, customers forgive you. A product that goes out the door bad kills the customer’s trust, and that’s hard to recover from even if it’s fixed later.
Wow, such great feedback on so many levels - great job everyone.
Inovelli has premium packaging for online sales, solid boxes with easy and complete instructions unlike many competitors who provide a link to a website. I use the different parts of the boxes as drawer dividers. From what I understand premium packaging can increase the price of a product, if removing the switch cover (which I never use because all my switches already have them) and using a nice but colorful box (HomeSeer has a great simple box) reduces the price to make them more attractable to consumers then I am all for it. To me a flashy box says the company cares more about the box than their product which I know if not the case; I am a Inovelli fan all the way and support their efforts.
I have a mix of Inovelli and HomeSeer switches, both great products.
I am mostly excited about the possibility of purchasing these at a retail store like The Home Depot or Lowes - would buy more often until the entire house is done.
I wonder how that mixture would be different if the Red dimmers hadn’t been out of stock for forever and a day. I bought some Black Series stuff because I needed some Inovelli NOW!!! Otherwise everything would have been Red Series; spending the extra $7 is a no-brainer.
You could remove the faceplates from the 1packs as far as I am concerned. 95% of the switches in my house are in 2-gang or larger j-boxes… If only I could remember to break off the heat-sync tabs BEFORE turning the power off.
Ditto on dropping the faceplates to save a few Yuan on each unit’s cost. My DW/WAF has artistic skills, and every switchplate in our house is a one-of-a-kind masterpiece that matches its room’s decor.
On a related note, you have no idea how tempting the plain white paddles on the switches are for someone who only sees them as a blank canvas…
I definitely got my 10000 steps in at the Walmart looking for an example. This is the best i could find, but any variation will make you stand out.
There was comment about not listing Z wave. From my personal experience, during my (ongoing) learning curve, when I pick up a box in the store, my first mistake in home automation was going the less costly route of wi-fi. So as I’m morphing away from wi-fi, when I’m looking in a store at items, I need to see a clear distinction that it is NOT wi-fi. I can tell you specifically when shopping for a (yes) SMART lock last year, I could have a box in my hand for a few minutes before I could figure whether or not it was wi-fi. Yes, I could be described as anal (I prefer pragmatic) but I think if I pick up a box, it is important to know what it is
Yes, if you sent a 4 pk I would not expect faceplates, jumpwires, connectors or extra instruction manuals.
Didnt even think of the cloud side, I know some chinese companies who would offer thier apps up, but that defeats the cost saving purposes.
Juste a nerd moment. You want any cost investment to have at least a 3x ROI. So at $0.20 a pack, it would take 140 sales to equal the cost of 1 black on off switch, So as long as the upgrade would net you one additional sale every 46.6 units (140/3). You would have a 300% ROI. So assuming one customer at Home Depot finds your switch and then buys 3 switches, you would just need 1 extra person to find and be sold by your product per 46.6 customers.
Its what apple does in its Mac vs PC commercials! Maybe you could do Zwave vs Zigbee? Then if they are really good maybe the Zwave alliance would offer some subsidies? (JK those guys probably wouldnt give anything).
I know right?! One day Inovelli…
Lol dont be greedy.
I suppose all leaders have thier flaws… I guess we can accept your macbook.
I assume you mean in that order?
Passion and Innovation do make sense. Apple goes for Innovation first and Presitge second. But i think if you read “How to Fascinate” by Sally Hogshead You might get some ideas for the marketing side with that one, its one of the best branding books I have read!
I know the feeling. My day job was completely just to be the highest paid Cog i could be, but the leaders in my life stick with me.
Makes sense. Is companies like Philips or Amazon willing to have cross-compatibility out of the box? So you could share thier hubs/Echos?
Sounds ambitious, how are you avoiding just making a better mousetrap? It seems your making an awesome Smartswitch, but it still is a smartswitch you have to have some electrical experience to wire in. I know its a limitation of the System itself, but I think thats the biggest hurdle keeping you from the masses.
Makes sense, I think hubs are where the big money is, since you get more control of your product and other groups. Everyone sucks up to smartthings after all.
The “Smarter Smartest Smart Switch, Smarter”
I honestly think it might be best to see what kind of hub is missing from the market before trying to add one. You cant go more DIY than Home Assistant, and you cant go more User-Basic than Hue. So something that fits between Smartthings and Hue might be a good start.
Except as soon as the Smarthome world knows you have a crappy starter hub, any other hub will probably get rejected. I was just thinking a Hub that does our switches amazingly, and then is open source for other things might work well. So the expectations are set. The real money in Hubs isnt in the hub itself, its in getting to control the market and the consumer to a degree.
You could try to coin “Intelligent switches” or if your feeling Ballsy “AI-Powered Switches”
If you want to take a note from apple. Stop with model numbers. Apple won the race in part by calling its computer the “Apple II” instead of VAX-11/780, TRS-80 Model 1, or any other complicated name. Amazon follows this by simply calling its products “Amazon Echo Plus” or “Amazon Echo Dot”.
One thing I would add would be super-simple DIY instructions. Like IKEA ones with words too.
I know it was requested in the roadmap thread, but do you have any updates on products? I’m specifically looking for the Zigbee switch and other Zigbee products. Do you have any dates?
Welcome @Thtry!
View the Roadmap as a 2002 Garmin GPS Roadmap. So the dates are more targets than concrete days. I know its coming soon though! @anon14959390
In regard to flap vs no flap - I think a flap showing the product has the potential to make the sale. There are a lot of crappy looking bulbs and switches that look ok in rendering, but in person look ugly. I won’t name names, but there’s one switch that I bought from another brand that I knew would look different than a standard paddle, but in the photo looked like it would be “ok”. Immediately upon opening I saw that it was more curved of a paddle, rather than how it appeared to me in the photo. Having a flap to see the product might help people realize how good these look compared to a regular paddle switch – that’s a huge reason for me I’ve continued to buy them, and one day will likely replace the aforementioned other-brand with Inovelli’s.
In my opinion, wifi stuff is picking up fast. Whilst I personally don’t like it, and continue to build my zigbee/z-wave network, I’ve had a few conversations with people who started smart-home projects and were unfamiliar with the concept of the hub. I think that the z-wave plus logo on the front would be a good indication that it is not wi-fi, with perhaps small text that says “Compatible hub required.” This might prevent frustrations with people who buy the product expecting it to be wifi if that’s all they know of.
I agree with the comment that “powered by inovelli” is confusing. No offense intended but in my mind, my switch is created by Inovelli, but is powered by Hubitat. Powered by being in my mind used as a term for the backbone.
I find that Red vs Black online chart to be invaluable when forgetting the differences between the two (especially when I’m recommending inovelli switches to someone else). I think it’d be very handy to have somewhere on the packaging.
This may sound silly, but when I first saw the signatures inside the box, I immediately thought it was cool. It helped me show how tight of a company it was, and it helped me realize who I was supporting by purchasing inovelli - it wasn’t a big faceless company – it was individuals. Of course, if you’re going retail, I’m not sure if that’s what you want, but I’m not a marketing expert, so I have no idea – but I thought I’d still mention that It was just a “neat” moment for me seeing it inside. However, the project name did throw me off at first.
Finally, I voted for blue. The reason for the blue was simple, I think that the red looks off in color, and makes the bulb look cheap because the color doesn’t seem vibrant. It gives me doubts about the ability to produce accurate colors. I’d like to see the blue more vibrant, but to me it looks more like a color someone would select, versus that red which feels more like a color someone would settle for when trying to achieve a red. For what it’s worth, I love the color red, and gravitate to it in a lot of situations (maybe that’s why I’ve only bought “Red Series”? hahaha).
Another analogy might be does it make sense for Dell to sell computers that are powered by Dell? Not really, but it does make sense if they are powered by Windows or powered by Intel processors. I think of “powered by” as an indication of a smaller chunk of technology inside the larger whole. The smaller chunk can’t be named the same as the larger whole.