So I’m very close to pulling the trigger on some switches but I’m still a bit confused on the benefit/differences between a multiway setup with aux switches and multiway with smart switches. Apologies that some of this might be my ignorance of zigbee binding protocol/logic and I haven’t stumbled onto the resource for best understanding that just yet. I feel like I may have found answers to snippets of my confusion in this thread but unfortunately not collected together.
My assumption is that an Aux switch will effectively be a clone of the Smart Blue switch upstream of it, but without the LED bar. Any presses on the Aux switch (taps, multitaps) will be interpreted/sent from the Smart Blue switch upstream. Therefore you’ve put your same configuration of the switch (with regards to multitaps/etc) in more than one physical location. Is this assumption correct?
With that being the baseline, where does a configuration with multiple Smart Blue switches fit into this? as I see it, I can assume three options:
A) the second Smart Blue switch is a clone of the first, like with an Aux switch, except the second switch now has a LED bar. Both switches have the same multitap behavior, and their LED bars are synchronized in pattern/color/etc.
B) the second Smart Blue acts completely independently of the first, you can have different multitap programming, different light bar settings, etc, and you’re triggering/controlling the first switches load as a function of programming.
C) somewhere in-between option A) & B), where certain functions are cloned between them (eg color bar dim % as seen in the video) but others are allowed to be different (eg LED color/pattern, multitap).
Again some of my lack of understanding regarding the above options may stem from a lack of understanding of zigbee binding behavior and I apologized for that.
The manual references in the Pre-Programming section a pair of options: ON-OFF / Dimmer / Smart, and Single-Pole / Dumb / Aux. Most of this I understand, but I don’t understand what the Smart setting is intended to be used for, and the language in the rest of the manual doesn’t present the Smart as a distinction of on/off/dimmer/etc. Is it perhaps for a switch with no load and can only control via scenes/binding or a hub interpreting/running automations, ie for the ‘Aux’ Smart switch(s) in a multiway setup?
Unfortunately the manual in it’s current state doesn’t clarify this for me. I see that ‘binding’ sections seem to be missing for the time being so perhaps those updates will fill in the gaps in my understanding.
Personally I can see value in having Smart switches instead of Aux switches if I’m able to program their multitaps differently and/or I can program the LED bars differently for notification purposes. Otherwise if multiway setups act as cloned switches the value proposition swings in the direction of picking Aux switches instead of Smart switches in multiway configurations.
In simpler terms please sell me on the benefits of multiway configs with all smart switches vs Smart & Aux in greater detail What can the additional Smart switches do that the Aux wouldn’t do in their place?